France v Ireland player ratings: Joe McCarthy delivers on impressive Six Nations debut

Joe McCarthy presents his younger brother Andrew with the match medal after the win – Getty Images/Harry Murphy

Ireland produced a near-complete display against a French side that lacked their usual panache even before Paul Willemse was shown a second yellow card.

Here, Telegraph Sport runs the rule over the performances in Marseille

France

15. Tomás Ramos

He is as reliable as ever at the back but will be frustrated by the lack of space created for him. He started his goals. 6/10

14. Damian Penaud

A few minutes shaky under high balls that Ireland took advantage of but he scored a neat try. 6/10

13. Gael Fickou

Fickou is not often part of the inferior midfield combination but the center was in Marseille. Leaky. 5/10

12. Jonathan Danty

Aki neutralized the wrecking ball and looked all over the sea. 4/10

Bundee Aki of Ireland in action against Jonathan Danty of France during the Guinness Six Nations Rugby Championship match between France and Ireland at the Stade Velodrome in Marseille, FranceBundee Aki of Ireland in action against Jonathan Danty of France during the Guinness Six Nations Rugby Championship match between France and Ireland at the Stade Velodrome in Marseille, France

Bundee Aki called around Jonathan Danty – Getty Images/Ramsey Cardy

11. Irom Moefana

He hasn’t had much to do but is clearly well-respected as he moves to the front late on and is being chased by Danty the man. 6/10

10. Mathieu Jalibert

A brilliant early run was undoubtedly the highlight but Jalibert struggled to impose and control as authoritatively as Crowley. 5/10

9. Mr. Lucu

The biggest boots to fill, with Dupont missing. Lucu’s kicking was handy but he was fouled and was fumbling around the rim. 4/10

1. Cyril Baille

The trademark dynamic behavior was causing problems in France and Furlong was toast at the scrum. 7/10

2. Peato Mauvaka

One of the World Cup stars had a quieter night. The French team had trouble – albeit a short lock – and Marchand may return next week. 6/10

3. Uini Atonio

The leading light of France. Some of the defensive shots were thunderous – and legal – and his scrummaging was faultless. 8/10

4. Paul Gabriellagues

His first appearance of the Galthié era. He didn’t put a wrong foot but barely overcame it, either. 6/10

5. Paul Willemse

The first strike was silly enough but he committed the same offense six minutes after returning to the pitch, having been given a get out of jail free card, bordering on insanity. The hope of French victory disappeared with him. 1/10

France's Paul Willemse leaves the field after being shown a red card by referee Karl Dickson, not pictured, during the Guinness Six Nations Rugby Championship match between France and Ireland at the Stade Velodrome in Marseille, FranceFrance's Paul Willemse leaves the field after being shown a red card by referee Karl Dickson, not pictured, during the Guinness Six Nations Rugby Championship match between France and Ireland at the Stade Velodrome in Marseille, France

Paul Willemse was shown a yellow card twice for almost the same offense – Getty Images/Harry Murphy

6. François Cross

Was the nuts and bolts as ever but France needed him to stand up after Willemse’s departure and he was on a muzzle. 5/10

7. Charles Ollivon

Nothing could be done to stop the ailing French line in the first half but he managed to fight his socks off defensively for good reason. 7/10

8. Gregory Alldritt (captain)

The work rate is huge but the massive Alldritt struggled with efficiency, especially compared to the other number Doris. 7/10

Replacements

Posolo Tuilagi was, at first, great. So, too, the front row was reserve and Bielle-Biarrey a handful out wide. 8/10

Ireland

15. Hugo Keenan

The most accurate goal in world rugby. Some of his attacking touches were outstanding but it is the way he reads the game that affects him the most. 9/10

14. Calvin Nash

The Six Nations forward looked completely at ease with the rigors of international rugby and performed with ease. 7/10

13. Robbie Henshaw

There was said to be an Irish weakness at outside center with Garry Ringrose missing. Henshaw proved that those fears were foolish. 8/10

12. Bundee Aki

He wore the most glorious download for the opening effort and looked every bit the player who rose to World XV status at last year’s show. 9/10

11. James Low

His left peg increases its value to this side tenfold. But it’s not just that; it is the will and aggression, too, to match the skill. 8/10

10. Jack Crowley

Another big shoes to fill. The passes that most delayed Beirne’s first try were eliminated. Immaculate kick except, too. 8/10

Ireland's Jack Crowley scores a conversion kick during the Guinness Six Nations match at the Orange Velodrome in Marseille, FranceIreland's Jack Crowley scores a conversion kick during the Guinness Six Nations match at the Orange Velodrome in Marseille, France

Jack Crowley was sure at No. 10 – PA Wire/Andrew Matthews

9. Jamison Gibson-Park

Fizded around the base and ordered his troops with certainty as usual. The only glaring error was a box kick straight out. 7/10

1. Andrew Porter

The effort could not be faulted and he is certainly still one of the best in the world but Atonio, then Aldegheri, troubled him. 6/10

2. Dan Sheehan

It was the ace’s try that put the result beyond doubt and his arrows were at the top of the line all afternoon. 7/10

3. Tadhg Furlong

Silky touch was shown in the attack but both Baille and Wardi put a lot of pressure on him at the scrummage. With France at 15 players it could be messy. 6/10

4. Joseph MacCarthy

Enthusiastic and loud at the start of the Six Nations. A locked man with a great future ahead of us. One careless fell to pass the one blot. 9/10

5. Tadhg Beirne

He ran the cutest line for his effort in the first half and is maturing in the force of nature, especially at the line-out. Could be a great time. 8/10

Ireland's Beirne stormed their way over to score their team's second try during the Guinness Six Nations match at the Orange Velodrome in MarseilleIreland's Beirne stormed their way over to score their team's second try during the Guinness Six Nations match at the Orange Velodrome in Marseille

Another roaming exhibition from Thadhg Beirne – PA Wire/Andrew Matthews

6. Peter O’Mahony (captain)

Rightly yellow carded for digging into France’s menacing chest but other than that O’Mahony’s tackle was superb. 8/10

7. Josh van der Flier

The flanker is not at his best in 2022 but the Irish backline was extremely fair and his bite played its part. 7/10

8. Caelan Doris

Alldritt doesn’t outplay much, especially on home turf, but Doris did. A big man but even then he punches above his weight – with swagger too. 9/10

Replacements

The cavalry took over where the starters left off, but against 14 players their positions were mostly routine. You still needed to send France away, mind you. 7/10

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *